Inaugural Post: SBG Reflections

Thanks to Fawn and Algebrainiac for providing the posts that finally got me off my ass to start blogging and to Bowman for the Angry Birds example that I’ll for sure use this fall. Here goes…

WHAT WORKED

  • Having students provide evidence of an improved understanding before reassessing – This really helped to ensure that students who reassessed did better the second time. Also it sent the message that reassessing was about deepening your understanding of a concept, not just being able to understand your errors so that you can “retake” a test. This evidence could have been generated in class, at home, with me, wherever.
  • Saying “No” to kids who didn’t have this evidence – Again I want students to have a high degree of confidence that they will demonstrate a deeper understanding on the reassessment.
  • Having students assess themselves – After revising their assessments students would complete one of these self-assessment forms in which they reflected upon their thinking and answered the following three questions: 1) What does this thinking prove that I understand? 2) What does this thinking show that I do not yet understand? and 3) What are my next steps in my learning?  We’re a 1-to-1 ipad school and I had students insert pictures from their assessment to support their answers using Remarks. This helped students to acknowledge learning successes, identify areas of need and create a plan for improvement.
  • Allowing students to reassess concepts from earlier quarters – Why should something be off limits in Q3 just because it was taught in Q1? The whole evidence thing helps here, as it means the kid has been doing something additionally to improve. I want to reward that.

WHAT DIDN’T WORK

  • Google form for reassessment sign-ups – Tried it but it just became one more thing to check. Apparently I wasn’t alone here but I might try and get my hands on the script that Algebrainiac uses that auto-e-mails me when someone has made a request to give it another shot.
  • Offering reassessment and relearning opportunities at the same time – I found it incredibly difficult to work with students to go over concepts while also trying to set up kids with reassessments. As our reassessment policy is department-wide we’re thinking of having all the kids taking reassessments after school to go to one teacher’s room (evidence would have been checked earlier by their classroom teacher). We’ll see how it goes.

WHAT I KNOW I CAN IMPROVE ON

  • Providing class time for relearning & reassessment – If I want to send the message that my class is about continuous improvement then I need to put my money where my mouth is and provide opportunities during class for that to happen. A colleague of mine gave me this awesome bingo cage that I may use to randomly choose a standard for in-class reassessment. By scheduling more frequent, smaller assessments on previously taught standards for the whole class I hope to diminish the need for student-initiated reassessments. I’ve also thought about dedicating the last 30 minutes of a class once every few weeks to review/reassessment.
  • Focusing on the Mathematical Practices – Like several of the other bloggers who have done similar posts I’m also interested in making the 8 practices a more central focus of my classroom next year. I’ve already dedicated one whole wall of my classroom next year for us to post student “illustrations” of each of the different practices in action.
  • Activating students as instructional resources for each other – Though students in my class always knew to seek out help from their peers I’d like to create more  formal structures for students who understand topics to provide instruction. Student-led “math meetings” during that 30-minute time maybe or student-created instructional videos using Explain Everything? I’m open to ideas.
  • Self-assessment form – I probably went through 10 different versions of the form linked above and still wasn’t totally happy with it at the end. I want students to have a consistent, easy channel to provide themselves with feedback on assessments and sometimes the process seemed a bit onerous.
  • Communication with parents – Like Fawn I could see requiring a parent’s signature as a nice, and most importantly, easy way to keep parents in the loop about their child’s learning. I’ve also thought about using the comment feature in our online Veracross gradebooks more creatively to provide feedback for parents on a specific assessment.
  • Developing assessment tasks – Like everyone else I’m always looking for better assessment tasks and ways to develop reassessments without sacrificing a significant amount of the time that I should be sleeping.

WHAT I’M STILL WONDERING ABOUT

  • Feedback, not grades – Reading Wiliam’s work has got me thinking critically about the ways students receive feedback on their learning in my class, and I’m eager to continue to try and move towards creating a classroom that revolves more around specific descriptive feedback than grades (be they traditional or standards-based).

Whew. Inaugural post complete! Thanks for reading!

5 thoughts on “Inaugural Post: SBG Reflections

  1. Woo Hoo!! Welcome to the MathTwitterBlogoSphere! Great first post and I look forward to reading more from you. I agree with having students provide evidence to reassess. I didn’t do this from the start, but required it when I had them start using the Google Form. I really like your idea of having students assess themselves…I most likely will be asking you about this more in the future. Props to you for allowing them to reassess from earlier quarters; I found the end of the quarter to be a nice break, but agree that the cut offs don’t need to be there. However, it is hard to change grades after they are finalized for me, so using the end of the quarter worked really well for me.

    I am happy to share the google form and script info with you. I really do LOVE it. I never check the form and it comes in my email very nice and easy to read. I have to use it because students can’t leave lunch to reassess without a pass an understandable process, but created a problem in the classroom with me always signing passes and students always asking me to sign them. I also didn’t accept the form if they didn’t reflect enough on their work.

    I am with you on communication with parents and the feedback parts. I look forward to hearing how you approach them!

    • Jessica,

      Thanks for the warm welcome!

      Student self-assessments worked really well but I want to try and do more in terms of co-constructing rubrics and discussing interesting mistakes as a class. Sometimes it felt like I was rushing the revision/reflection/self-assessment part to get to the next topic. I’m always wrestling with how to find the time for students to get, give and use meaningful feedback. Hopefully next year will be better.

      I totally agree that those breaks from reassessment and grading are very necessary, otherwise it can totally dominate your life! I’m hoping that moving some of the reassessment into the regular class period will alleviate some of that for me but we’ll see.

      Thanks so much for the feedback!

  2. I’m definitely going to be looking at this list as I make changes to my own system. Thanks for the great documentation here.

  3. Thank you, Jake, for this thorough SBG review. Your self-assessment form is another reminder that I need to seriously look into creating similar because it’s an integral part of learning. I don’t restrict kids from reassessing previous quarter’s stuff, but I highly doubt my kids would request to do so on their own. The contents are sequential enough that they’d need to learn previous skills to be successful so I think this gets factored in with their self-assessment.

    I really like your idea of “activating students as instructional resources for each other.” While this happens informally to some extent, I want to dedicate more time and space to this so it becomes a viable option.

    William’s book is a winner here.

    Thank you again, Jake. Much appreciate the shout out here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s